Broken Leg Scooter vs. Crutches – Which is Better?

June 26, 2018 • By Sophia Smith
The estimated reading time is 3 minutes

Right after a leg injury, your doctor will recommend you to either use a broken leg scooter or a crutch. You would have been happier to not choose either, but your given situation propels you to choose between the two. You realize that an assistive device will help you enhance mobility and reduce dependency on people. However, when you have to choose between the two, what could be better? Below we will share with you the pros and cons of using either of the two walking aids. It will help you understand what suits you more and you can buy the right product as your walking aid. (1)

  1. Crutches


If you have a great strength in your upper body and you can push yourself to stay mobile, you can use crutches. People with low upper body strength will walk slower than the latter. Once you figure out how to use crutches, you will be able to use it properly. There are thousands of people who walk with crutches and go to work and live a normal life. These are comparatively cheaper and can be found anywhere.


Crutches are tough to maneuver as you have to put all your weight on the armpits. It can feel risky to irritate them, and you can’t neglect the wear and tear that happens on your shoulders. It can also leave a negative impact on your back and wrist. Many people with injured legs feel unsafe to use crutches. People who use crutches find it tough to open a door, pick things from the ground, and so on. It is also tough to climb up stairs, especially if you are just a beginner at this walking aid. Crutches can also seem like clunky items that keep falling over and don’t always get through car doors or even doorways.

  1. Broken leg scooter


Knee walkers are low to the floors and stable compared to crutches. They are cushioned for space and comfort and let you rest the injured leg. You don’t have to put weight on that leg at all, compared to other walking aids. It also lets you move around swiftly once you can maneuver it well. When you pause to do something, both your hands are free while your leg still has the support. These are simple to use and don’t need upper body strength. These are less clunky than crutches and have low chances of slipping on wet surfaces. (2)


Knee walkers need you to keep your back in a neutral position. It can cause a problem if you lean too much ahead or to the back or to one side. The walking aid takes more time to get used to. For some surfaces, they can be slower than crutches. These also don’t help you cross stairs easily and are more expensive than crutches.

In an overall, we assume that you will need help to climb up and down the stairs. Otherwise, the broken leg scooter is a better option to choose. They help you move around easily, keep your back straight, and help you feel independent. It also lets you stand and complete chores. Consider this as a better option and become agiler than before.

Sophia Smith

She is a renowned nutritionist and freelance writer whose topics of interest include healthy living and healthy eating. She is passionate about introducing new and delicious healthy meals while balancing her time between cooking and going to the gym. Her mission is to change the life of as many people as she can and make them the best version of themselves.
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram